Scott McTominay has emerged as a key figure for both Scotland and Napoli, but will the former Manchester United midfielder consider returning to the Premier League? Kenny Miller has shared with GOAL his view that the rejuvenated 29-year-old has little reason to retrace his steps in England after achieving both professional and personal fulfilment in Italy.

During the summer of 2024, the 72-cap Scotland international made a bold decision to leave Old Trafford when Manchester United opened the door for his departure. The move surprised many, as did his eventual destination – Napoli.

Following a £26 million ($34m) transfer, McTominay embraced a fresh challenge far from familiar surroundings. Napoli’s faith in him has been richly rewarded with a Serie A title, an MVP award, and 27 goals across 80 appearances in all competitions.

Often deployed in a holding role during his Manchester United days and not always a regular starter, McTominay has flourished in Italy by adopting a more dynamic, attack-minded approach. Off the pitch, he has settled well with his partner, Cam Reading, and has become a fan favourite among supporters who once idolised Argentine legend Diego Maradona.

Following his impressive performances, speculation about a potential Premier League return has naturally surfaced. When asked whether McTominay should consider such a move, former Scotland striker Kenny Miller – speaking on behalf of BetGoodwin – told GOAL: “Only Scott can answer how he feels. It looks like he's absolutely loved life in Italy. It looks like his whole image has changed!”

Miller added: “He's really adapted to life in Naples. He's clearly enjoying his football. When you’re winning trophies, claiming the MVP award in your first season, and being embraced by the supporters, it’s something truly special.”

“There will definitely be clubs eager to sign Scott McTominay – that’s the nature of football. But it might take something exceptional to entice him away, given how adored he is by the fans. That kind of respect and affection is something every player values.”

“When you’re comfortable and playing your best football, it’s not always easy to replicate that elsewhere. Different coaches, styles, and expectations can all affect your performances and happiness. So, he’ll have a lot to think about if he ever considers moving.”

“However, if Scott did decide he wanted a change, and if that meant returning to the Premier League, I’ve no doubt there would be plenty of suitors eager to bring him back.”

McTominay’s leadership role with Scotland has also grown significantly. After shining for Napoli, he is now performing on the biggest international stage. Scotland began their first World Cup campaign since 1998 with a 1-0 victory over Haiti, followed by a narrow 1-0 loss to Morocco.

The Scots are now preparing for a high-profile clash with Brazil in Miami on Wednesday, with a historic knockout-stage appearance within reach. McTominay is expected to play a crucial role in that mission.

Speaking about McTominay’s development and ability to handle pressure, Miller said: “He’s really embraced that leadership role, not just for Scotland but also at Napoli. Winning the league and earning the MVP award in his debut season, then being named in the Ballon d’Or top 20, that elevates you to a different level – and he’s done exactly that.”

“His performances for the national team have improved immensely over the past five or six years. He’s become a fantastic footballer, plain and simple.”

“That said, I’m always wary of placing too much responsibility on one player – that’s rarely how football works unless you’re the best in the world! Scotland have quality players around Scott too. He’s probably our best, but the team’s strength lies in its unity, not individual brilliance. Within that, though, individuals like Scott can still shine.”

“John McGinn consistently contributes goals, and I rate Ben Gannon-Doak highly – he offers something Scotland have lacked for a long time. Whether he starts or comes off the bench, he can make a real impact.”

“Given what Scott has achieved over the past few seasons, he’s handling the pressure well. He looks composed and confident.”

“Major tournaments bring challenges – you’re facing top teams, and nothing comes easy. Even the win against Haiti wasn’t straightforward. You can’t just show up at a World Cup and expect to dominate.”

“I think Scott has played a slightly different role recently. While he still drives forward and poses a goal threat, he’s taken on more responsibility in the build-up phase, helping to control possession and tempo – especially in Billy Gilmour’s absence.”

“He’s shown he can do everything as a midfielder – a true all-rounder. Even when playing deeper, he still gets into the box and remains a scoring threat. So, his new responsibilities aren’t limiting him; they’re just expanding his influence.”

Scotland’s hopes of reaching the knockout stages at the 2026 World Cup may hinge on securing a third-place finish in Group C, which could be enough to progress to the last-32. Any positive result against Brazil would significantly boost their chances and potentially make history.

However, they’ll need to find a way to contain Brazil’s attacking stars, including Vinicius Junior and possibly Neymar, who might return from injury. At the same time, Scotland will look to create the chances McTominay needs to make a decisive impact in the final third.