DON’T MISS A MOMENT OF THE WORLD CUP

England’s Ideal XI for the Crucial World Cup Semi-Final Against Argentina: Why Thomas Tuchel Might Need a Fresh Approach on the Right Flank to Secure a Place in the Final

Now comes the defining stage. England have enjoyed, truthfully speaking, a relatively favourable run in this World Cup so far. Their clash with Mexico at the Azteca Stadium was a genuine examination, but they have yet to encounter a side that is unarguably superior. That changes now, as they face Argentina — the reigning champions, led by none other than Lionel Messi.

The Albiceleste have not exactly been at their fluent best during this tournament. Much like England, they have often depended on their superstar to deliver in crucial moments. Yet, history shows they tend to rise to the occasion when the stakes are highest. After all, this is largely the same core that triumphed in two tight finals — the 2022 World Cup and the 2024 Copa America. It would be unwise to underestimate Messi when the big games arrive.

So, what should England’s plan be? The positive news is that the squad is almost at full strength. Declan Rice is expected to be fit. Bukayo Saka seems to be finding a bit more rhythm. And, of course, Jude Bellingham continues to shine. GOAL once again steps into Football Manager territory, selecting the ideal starting eleven for Thomas Tuchel’s England ahead of their massive World Cup semi-final clash with long-time rivals Argentina.

Goalkeeper: Jordan Pickford

Jordan Pickford’s tournament has gone from shaky to highly assured. His heroics at the Azteca will be remembered as one of England’s standout goalkeeping displays. To be fair, Pickford has consistently delivered when the national team has needed him most.

One could argue his misjudgment of the cross-shot leading to Norway’s opening goal was disappointing. Still, had he managed to save it, the conversation would have been, “What a save, Jordan!” His place in the lineup is beyond dispute.

Right-Back: Reece James

He’s back! Tuchel handed Reece James a useful spell against Norway, and the defender clocked nearly 50 minutes in his comeback from a hamstring injury, contributing both at right-back and in central midfield.

James’ introduction proved crucial, helping England regain control when they needed it most. It remains uncertain if he can complete a full 90 minutes, but Djed Spence is ready to step in if required — and that competition can only help.

Centre-Back: Ezri Konsa

Ezri Konsa arguably looked more comfortable at right-back than his natural central position, but the reality is that John Stones cannot be relied upon to play two 90-minute matches within a week, especially after an injury-affected season for Manchester City. Stones will likely be the impact option from the bench, while Konsa starts alongside Guehi.

Centre-Back: Marc Guehi

Marc Guehi produced a commanding performance against Norway. England needed a defender capable of making life difficult for Erling Haaland — and while stopping the Manchester City striker outright is nearly impossible, Guehi managed to limit his influence with a brave, physical display.

Left-Back: Nico O'Reilly

Nico O'Reilly’s defensive abilities have been questioned throughout this tournament. Now, he faces the ultimate test — marking Lionel Messi. The Argentine star has drifted toward the right in recent matches, meaning O'Reilly will have to provide consistent defensive support against the eight-time Ballon d’Or winner. It will be the biggest challenge of his young career, and England will be hoping he is ready for it.

Central Midfield: Elliot Anderson

Elliot Anderson was the unsung hero in the victory over Norway. He anchored the middle of the park while the rest of the team rotated around him. His clever play — including drawing a crucial foul from Haaland that negated what could have been a Norwegian winner — showcased why Manchester City invested heavily in him.

Central Midfield: Declan Rice

After the Norway match, it emerged that Declan Rice had spent much of the previous three days in bed recovering from illness. That he managed to complete 45 minutes before Tuchel substituted him was impressive. With a few more days to recover, Rice should be fully fit for Wednesday’s semi-final — the most significant match of his England career thus far.

Attacking Midfield: Jude Bellingham

No explanation needed here — Jude Bellingham’s inclusion speaks for itself.

Right Wing: Bukayo Saka

It’s a big test for Bukayo Saka. The Arsenal winger still appears to be carrying a knock, and although he provided a smart assist against Mexico, his movement continues to look laboured. Nevertheless, his work rate and defensive tracking will be vital against Argentina’s attacking threats.

Striker: Harry Kane

Harry Kane may not have been at his sharpest against Norway, but he remains England’s most dependable forward. As Tuchel put it, “Get the ball to Harry and Jude, and they will do the rest.” Kane’s leadership and finishing instinct will again be critical.

Left Wing: Anthony Gordon

After a tough outing against Ghana, where Anthony Gordon perhaps faced undue criticism, he has since bounced back superbly. Gordon was excellent at the Azteca, influential in the Norway match, and has demonstrated that he offers more all-round impact than Marcus Rashford — even if Barcelona’s former winger remains the more clinical finisher. Gordon has earned his starting place for this semi-final.