The FIFA World Cup semifinals unfolded with entirely different narratives, yet they have delivered a mouth-watering final between two exceptional sides.

The much-anticipated final is now confirmed—and the semifinals offered every ounce of drama fans could have hoped for. The clash between France and Spain perfectly captured the contrast between a collection of talented individuals and a cohesive footballing unit. France dazzled in attack throughout the tournament, but when forced to adapt tactically and face a technically superior opponent, they faltered. Spain’s victory was fully deserved.

In contrast, the England versus Argentina semi was more of a psychological collapse than a footballing contest. The weight of history seemed to smother both teams during the first half, which barely resembled a proper match. Tempers flared, fouls flew, and when England finally found the net, they seemed to forget how to play. Argentina’s seemingly unbreakable resilience—what many call their ‘plot armour’—kicked in, with two late goals keeping Lionel Messi’s dream of consecutive World Cup titles alive.

Both semifinals were captivating for entirely different reasons and have set up a blockbuster final. Spain appear the more complete team, yet Argentina have Messi. It’s a clash too close to call. GOAL’s writers reflect and look ahead in the latest edition of The Rondo.

Thoughts on the semifinals?

Tom Hindle: Bitterly disappointing for both England and France. Each match turned on major tactical mistakes. Didier Deschamps committed a huge error by not fielding a third midfielder—someone like Manu Kone could have provided much-needed balance. As widely discussed, there was no justification for Thomas Tuchel’s decision to sit deep. England looked set for victory before retreating into their shell. Credit, though, to Argentina, whose resilience seems limitless.

Ryan Tolmich: The two strongest sides advanced. Not necessarily the most talented, but definitely the strongest in belief and mentality. Spain completely overwhelmed France, while Argentina outlasted England. Both teams triumphed because of conviction more than anything else—and that’s what makes them so formidable.

What was the biggest reason behind England’s defeat on Wednesday?

TH: It’s the same psychological scar that has haunted English football for generations. Whenever the Three Lions find themselves in a position of opportunity, they tend to implode. This was another case of England squandering their lead. Instead of pressing on, they chose to sit back—and were duly punished by a team that sensed weakness.

RT: It was a mix of England’s self-doubt and Argentina’s self-belief. After taking the lead, England played timidly, despite bringing in Thomas Tuchel specifically to eliminate that fear factor. Argentina, on the other hand, never lost faith. Given that contrast, the result felt inevitable.

Should England continue with Thomas Tuchel?

TH: Absolutely. He’s under contract and remains a top-tier coach. This was a poor decision, but not one that warrants dismissal.

RT: Probably yes. There aren’t many better managers available at the international level, even if he did mismanage this game. Let’s see whether he learns from it and prepares England properly for the upcoming European Championships.

What caused France’s collapse against Spain?

TH: They simply couldn’t get possession. Spain’s ability to control matches is unmatched. France failed to press effectively, leaving themselves outnumbered and outclassed in midfield.

RT: France ran into a powerhouse. Spain prevented them from executing any of their plans. It looked effortless from Spain, but that’s down to their mastery of midfield control—a level few teams can disrupt. For years now, no one has truly found a solution to Spain’s command of the ball.

Who wins on Sunday?

TH: Argentina. Messi to lift back-to-back titles.

RT: Logic suggests Spain, but can you really bet against Argentina? They always seem to find a way. Until they don’t, it’s wise to back Messi and company to do it again.

Is Messi the best player at this World Cup? Is this run among the greatest in tournament history?

TH: Ironically, before Wednesday, Jude Bellingham might have edged it, with Messi just behind. Bellingham had been involved in seven of England’s goals heading into that match, but he couldn’t impose himself this time. Given Messi’s comeback performance and two more assists, the crown must go to him now.

RT: He’s certainly in the top two or three performers of this World Cup, though the final will determine everything. His goal contributions have been extraordinary, but other stars have impressed too. Ultimately, winning the final is what counts—and if Messi does that, his place in history will be sealed.