NPS vs UPS: Which Pension Scheme Is Better for Government Employees? Full Breakdown of Benefits, Contributions & Calculations
Siddhi Jain April 11, 2025 10:15 PM

Government employees have a crucial decision to make before June 2025—whether to continue with the National Pension System (NPS) or opt for the newly introduced Unified Pension Scheme (UPS). Both options come with their own set of features, benefits, and limitations, which can leave many employees puzzled. In this article, we will break down how pensions are calculated under the new UPS model, compare it with the existing NPS, and help you figure out which one might suit you better.

NPS vs UPS: Key Similarities and Differences

Let’s start with the common ground. Both pension schemes require employees to contribute 10% of their basic salary plus dearness allowance (DA). However, the government's contribution varies under each scheme.

Feature NPS (National Pension System) UPS (Unified Pension Scheme)
Employee Contribution 10% 10%
Government Contribution 14% 10%
Additional Government Support None 8.5% (into a special corpus)
Equity Investment Cap Up to 50% Up to 50%
Default Equity Exposure 25% 25%

While both schemes allow up to 50% equity exposure, the default exposure is set at 25% for both. The biggest structural difference lies in how the pension benefits are calculated and disbursed.

How Pensions Are Calculated in UPS

Under the NPS, upon retirement, an employee can withdraw 60% of the accumulated corpus as a lump sum, and the remaining 40% is converted into a monthly pension through annuity purchases.

On the other hand, the UPS uses a formula-based approach to determine pension, ensuring a more predictable income stream. Here's how the UPS pension is calculated:

UPS Pension = 50% × P + (Q ÷ 300) + (IC ÷ BC)

  • P = Average basic salary over the last 12 months

  • Q = Total number of months in service

  • IC = Total individual contribution towards pension

  • BC = A fixed benchmark amount for calculation

This formula provides a guaranteed pension, typically around 50% of your last drawn basic salary, along with benefits from your personal pension fund.

Example: How Much Will You Get at Retirement?

To better understand the financial outcomes of both schemes, let’s take an example.

Suppose an employee works for 25 years, starting with a monthly basic salary of ₹50,000, which increases by 5% annually.

  • Under UPS:

    • Estimated monthly pension: ₹84,658

    • One-time lump sum payout: ₹8.45 lakh

  • Under NPS:

    • Estimated total corpus: ₹2.25 crore

    • Withdrawable lump sum (60%): ₹1.35 crore

    • Remaining ₹90 lakh used for pension: Monthly pension of ₹86,250

While the NPS offers a larger withdrawal and potential for higher returns based on market performance, UPS provides a fixed and secure pension, ideal for those seeking stability.

Which Pension Scheme Should You Choose?

Your choice between NPS and UPS should be based on your career plans, risk tolerance, and retirement goals.

If you… Best Option
Plan to serve in government until retirement UPS
Prefer investment flexibility and higher returns NPS
Might leave government service early NPS
Want guaranteed pension and inflation protection UPS

Final Thoughts

The new Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) brings a structured and secure retirement plan for government employees who prefer a predictable income post-retirement. Meanwhile, the National Pension System (NPS) offers greater flexibility and market-linked returns, making it attractive for employees who are open to calculated risks and may consider alternate career paths.

Whichever path you choose, make sure to evaluate your financial goals, job security, and risk appetite before the June 2025 deadline. A well-informed decision today can ensure a secure and stress-free retirement tomorrow.

© Copyright @2025 LIDEA. All Rights Reserved.