More than 215 vice-chancellors, former vice-chancellors and academicians have written an open letter to Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi, expressing disappointment over her remark describing IIT Madras Director Prof V Kamakoti as a "Gaumutra expert". The signatories said Parliament should remain a forum for reasoned debate and argued that scholars should be judged on their work and ideas rather than labels or ridicule.
In the letter addressed to Priyanka Gandhi, the academics said Parliament has always been expected to be a platform where ideas are debated seriously, disagreements are expressed respectfully and individuals are assessed on the strength of their arguments rather than mocked or misrepresented.
Referring to her remarks about Prof Kamakoti, they said they were disappointed by her description of the IIT Madras Director as a "Gaumutra expert". Whether intended as satire or political rhetoric, the comment raised concerns that went beyond an individual, the letter stated.
The signatories noted that Prof Kamakoti heads one of India's leading scientific and technological institutions and highlighted his academic and professional credentials.
Kharge Questions Use Of Pellet Guns On Students, Demands Amit Shah's Resignation
The letter said Prof Kamakoti holds an MS and a PhD in Computer Science and Engineering from IIT Madras. It added that he has published more than 150 research papers, participated in over 50 research and development projects and received several honours, including the DRDO Academic Excellence Award and the Indian Electronics and Semiconductor Association's Techno Visionary Award.
The signatories also stated that he played a key role in developing India's first industry-grade microprocessor, describing him as one of the country's foremost technical experts.
According to the letter, every academic has the right to present hypotheses, discuss traditional knowledge and participate in scientific discourse. It argued that dismissing a scholar through labels rather than engaging with their ideas risks undermining the scientific temper that the Constitution encourages every citizen to develop.
The letter added that scientific temper does not simply mean questioning unconventional ideas but also examining claims impartially before accepting or rejecting them.
The controversy stems from Priyanka Gandhi's remarks made on July 28, during a discussion on an examination reform Bill, when she questioned the composition of a government-appointed high-powered task force and referred to Prof. Kamakoti as a "Gaumutra expert".
OPINION | Cockroach Protest Not Similar To Neighbourhood's Gen-Z Movements
Dr. Santishri Dhulipudi Pandit – Vice Chancellor, Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU)
Dr. Sachin Chaturvedi – Vice Chancellor, Nalanda University
Dr. Rajiv Kumar – Former Vice Chairman, NITI Aayog
Dr. Pankaj Mittal – Secretary General, Association of Indian Universities (AIU)
Dr. Anil Sahasrabudhe – Former Chairman, AICTE and NAAC
Dr. G.D. Yadav – Padma Shri awardee; Former Vice Chancellor, Institute of Chemical Technology (ICT), Mumbai
Dr. Devendra Jalihal – Director, IIT Guwahati
Dr. Suman Chakraborty – Director, IIT Kharagpur
Dr. Amit Patra – Director, IIT (BHU), Varanasi
Dr. Rajat Moona – Director, IIT Gandhinagar
Dr. Rajeev Ahuja – Director, IIT Ropar
Dr. K.K. Pant – Director, IIT Roorkee
Dr. V.R. Desai – Director, IIT Dharwad
Dr. Bharat Bhasker – Director, IIM Ahmedabad
Dr. Manoj Kumar Tiwari – Director, IIM Mumbai
Dr. Vinita Sahay – Director, IIM Bodh Gaya
Dr. Prafull Agnihotri – Director, IIM Sirmaur
Dr. Alok K. Rai – Director, IIM Calcutta
Dr. M. Chandrashekhar – Director, IIM Visakhapatnam
Dr. Devika Madalli – Director, INFLIBNET
Dr. Ganesan Kannabiran – Director, NAAC
Dr. D.P. Agarwal – Former Chairman, UPSC
Dr. Umesh Chandra Sharma – President, Veterinary Council of India
Dr. B.R. Kamboj – Vice Chancellor, Haryana Agriculture University, Hisar
